Yuille born december 1, 1941 in montreal, quebec is a canadian psychologist whose research interests include forensic psychology, victim and witness memory, suspect memory, trauma and memory, stress and memory, child sexual abuse, interview techniques, serial crimes, and credibility assessment. However, a study by yuille and cutshall 1986 contradicts the importance of stress in influencing eyewitness memory. A study by loftus and palmer 1974 into the accuracy of eye witness testimony aimed to find out if changing the wording of a question could distort ones ability to recall from memory an event. Yuille and cutshall investigated the effect of anxiety in a real life shooting, in which one person was killed and another person seriously wounded. Analysis of the statements of victims, witnesses and suspects. Alevel psychology marked by, 2016 your bibliography. To look at how susceptible eyewitnesses are to distortion by including leading questions procedure. Ebscohost serves thousands of libraries with premium essays, articles and other content including a case study of eyewitness memory of a crime. The incident took place on a major thoroughfare in midafternoon. A real life case study by yuille and cutshall 1986 contradicts the results of loftus 1979 and the weapon focus effect. Conclusions this was the first case study of eyewitness testimony which was.
The accuracy and suggestibility of children s memory for neutral and. Competency yuille and cutshall were competent researchers and the interviews used to compare the accuracy against were carried out by competent police officers. They showed that witnesses of a real life incident a gun shooting outside a gun shop in canada had remarkable accurate memories of a stressful event involving weapons. Yuille and cutshall 1986 leading questions and eyewitnessess duration. Because experimental designs are attractive, under labora. Background to yuille and cutshall 1986 one spring afternoon in vancouver, canada, a thief entered a gun shop, tied up the owner and stole some money and guns. To study the effectiveness of eyewitness testimony using real eyewitnesses 2. These figures were even higher for the research interview, which asked additional questions that were of. A thief stole guns and money, but was shot six times and died. List 1986 reported favourable differences among younger adults in both quantity and.
Leading questions might affect the authenticity of eyewitness testimony, as they might challenge the confidence of the people about the things they saw. If the event was stressful and upsetting, witnesses would be hesitant to participate in any form of reconstruction. Overall, yuille and cutshall 1986 found that the police interview had rendered a total of 392 action, 180 person description, and 78 object description details, many of which turned out to be correct 82%, 76%, and 89%, respectively. The aim of the yuille and cutshall study of 1986 is to investigate the precision of eyewitness testimonies from a real crime. Research wouldnt interfere with a case because the death of the thief closed the file. Yuille and cutshall 1986 conducted a field study in which participants who had witnessed a shooting incident were interviewed. Yuille and cutshall s initial purpose for this research study was to criticize and challenge loftus and palmers study of 1974. With the exception of one witness, all reported eventrelated stress, but for some this appeared about half an hour after the incident. The rest of the themes were mentioned less frequently and. During the course of the robbery the shop owner was shot. For instance, a study that was conducted in 1986 by yuille and cutshall, negated the influence of the presence of weapon on the eyewitness testimony. Yuille and cutshall a2 psychology your reading intentions are private to you and will not be shown to other users.
Retention interval and eyewitness memory for events. The effect of mood context on the accuracy of eyewitness testimony. This chapter examines the appropriateness of statement analysis in the evaluation of adult eyewitness testimony. Eyewitness memory, in the case of eyewitness memory, a study by loftus and palmer suggests that eyewitness memory is highly vulnerable.
Therefore, field observation are required to help generalise lab study findings. Multiple studies examining real crimes in police case files or utilizing actual. An archival study of eyewitness memory of the titanic s. Overall, yuille and cutshall 1986 found that the police interview had rendered a total of 392 action, 180 person description, and 78 object description details. We realize that file research lacks the experimental control of laboratory studies. Yuille and cutshall 1986 conducted interviews on witnesses of a violent. All of the witnesses were interviewed by the investigating police, and witnesses aged 1532 yrs agreed to a research interview 45 mo after the event. Aims yuille and cutshall 1986 wanted to investigate the accuracy in recall of eyewitnesses to a real crime, in response to leading questions and over time. Thirteen participants, who all witnessed a gun shooting incident, were interviewed and asked to recall the event. The current study arousal may affect the accuracy of eyewitness memory. Aim to investigate the accuracy of recall in eyewitness to real crimes in response to leading questions participants witnesses to a crime where a gun shop was robbed and the owner left the shop to get his number plate but the man tried to. Overall, the study demonstrated that memories of stressful events could be accurate regardless of the interview time. In response to this deficit of diversity, this chapter reports the results of an inquiry into actual police case files. One feature that emerged from our police file research is the frequency with.
The accuracy and suggestibility of 30 rst grade children who witnessed. A case study of accuracy and confidence after 3 months. What links here related changes upload file special pages permanent link page. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Yuille and cutshall made several important findings. However, a study by yuille and cutshall 1986 contradicts the importance of weapon focus in influencing eyewitness memory. Findingsfrom studies on free recall of events in young and older adults have revealed discrepancies. Does the weapon focus effect influence eyewitness testimony. Daylen was published in the 1986 study on eyewitness effectiveness which aimed to investigate the accuracy of recall in eyewitness testimonies by using a real crime and real eyewitnesses. A longitudinal study by porter and peace 2007 further supports the notion that trauma can enhance memory. Our data from police case files, however, represent a degree of realism and a range of variables impossible to simulate in a laboratory setting. False memories for a robbery in young and older adults. Background to yuille and cutshall, 1986 one spring afternoon in vancouver, canada, a thief entered a gun shop, tied up the owner and stole some money and guns.
In comparing initial police reports with researcher interviews regarding the. To look at the accuracy of ewt to assess changes over time immediately compared to 45 months later. Even the study conducted by loftus didnt rule out the fact that the fixation on weapon could actually be associated with the human tendency to focus more on any unusual item. Daylen previously cutshall is a boardcertified psychologist. The accuracy and suggestibility of childrens memory for. Yuille and cutshall interviewed real witnesses of a real crime. Tollestrup, turtle, and yuille 1994 examined police files for robber y and fraud cases to determine the congruency between the eyewitnesses descriptions o f various. They used witnesses who had observed a gun shooting incident on a spring afternoon in vancouver, canada. Flashbulb memories scoring system people who witness real life events may be fairly resistant to a reconstruction of the event that took place. Evaluation of yuille and cutshall 1986 by gemma ward on. Trauma and cognitive science exploring the nature of.
68 1231 450 1038 616 60 515 544 610 653 1039 430 1432 1070 124 1206 1284 722 419 774 972 769 1080 178 176 428 452 647 756 985 1329 1051 874 1471 647 758 695 671